|
FPSC Suitability Clause | CSS candidates assigned groups
FPSC Suitability Clause 'victims' to appeal before high courts
Lahore, April 25, 2008: The 'victims' of the Federal
Public Service Commission (FPSC)'s Suitability Clause will file petitions before
high courts across the country, seeking a stay order against their appointments,
they said on Thursday.
At least 21 Central Superior Services
(CSS) examination candidates have fallen 'victim' to the Suitability
Clause.
Falak Sher (number 57 on the merit list), a candidate from
Punjab, has been declared 'unsuitable' for a job in the District Management
Group (DMG) and has, instead, been assigned to the Customs Department. Sher has
decided to lead other disgruntled candidates from Punjab within a few days to
file an appeal in the Lahore High Court (LHC) to protest their employment
designations.
Syed Mashkoor Ali (179 on the merit list) and Fuad Ghaffar
Soomro (116 on the list) belong to Sindh and have been assigned to the Income
Tax Department instead of the Customs and the Police (which had been their
preferences). They will lead other disgruntled candidates from Sindh to file a
petition in the Sindh High Court.
Dr Mohammad Junaid (merit number 154),
a candidate from Balochistan, has been assigned a post in the Pakistan Railways
instead of the police.
He will lead other disgruntled candidates from
Balochistan and file a petition in the Balochistan High Court within a few days
for a stay order against their assignations under the Suitability
Clause.
Mehmoodur Rehman Khattak (merit 37) has been assigned to the
Customs Department instead of his preferred choice of the DMG. He will lead the
NWFP's Suitability Clause 'victims'.
The five men, who will lead their
fellow candidates, said on Monday that they would try to get the
stay order after which they would submit their applications to the FPSC office.
They said they were sure that the FPSC would reject their applications, adding
that if this proved to be the case, they would take their appeals to the high
courts.
The FPSC issued the final assignation list on April 23 in which
189 CSS candidates were appointed to occupational groups and services. The
candidates have been asked to send their acceptance letters via priority mail to
the Establishment Division within 15 days otherwise their "offers will be
cancelled and no representation [for them] will be entertained".
Dr
Ishrat Hussain, chairman of the National Commission on Government Reforms, said that the Suitability Clause would not the bar anyone from sitting
the National Executive Service promotion examination.
The candidates said
that, previously, the Suitability Clause had been initiated only on two or three
candidates every year, which disturbed the complete merit list. This was the
reason why the FPSC had not used the Suitability Clause for the last five years,
the five men said. "Pakistan is already facing a major brain drain and this step
[the use of the clause] has only served to emotionally disturb the most
competent brains of the country who have chosen careers in civil service," they
added.
They said that most of the candidates who had suffered because of
the clause were from backward areas of the country. They said that this was the
first time since the establishment of the FPSC in 1977 that the clause had been
used in "such a reckless manner". They said its implementation was nothing less
than "sheer discrimination".
Dr Junaid, leading the candidates from
Balochistan, noted that he had been denied a job in the Income Tax Department
even though it had two vacant seats and his merit (154) rendered him eligible to
fill one of the posts. He said that ironically, a person with a lower merit
(162) was appointed to the police, one of the departments that requires the
highest merit. "Declaring me unsuitable for the top seven occupational groups is
a violation of my constitutional rights," he said.
Syed Mashkoor Ali said
that he had been declared unsuitable for the Customs Department and suitable for
the Income Tax Department despite the fact that both departments were
subsidiaries of the Federal Board of Revenue and were financial services. Ali is
already working at the Income Tax Department.
Falak Sher said he had been
working at the Income Tax group (34 common). He said the FPSC had declared him
ineligible for both the police and DMG, even after he had received clearance
from the FPSC commission. He was placed at number 57 on the merit list. A seat
in the police was given to a candidate with a merit of 162, while those with
merit numbers 119, 143 and 154 were denied the job.
The candidates also
pointed out another instance in which Saima Saleem, who is physically disabled
and placed sixth on the merit list, was appointed to the Foreign Services group.
Other candidates said that this was the first time that a disabled person had
been appointed to this department. An FPSC official said that if the candidates
had applied to the FPSC first, they would get "all answers on their rights". He
said the FPSC chairman had the discretionary power to implement the Suitability
Clause on a case-by-case basis. He said the candidates had the right to appeal
to the FPSC, but they did not have the right to challenge the commission's
decision.
189 CSS candidates assigned to groups or services
Islamabad: The Federal Public Service Commission has assigned 189
successful candidates of the 2007 Competitive Examination to various
occupational groups and services, a press release said on Wednesday.
It
asked all candidates, except those medically deferred, to send acceptance of
through Urgent Mail Service within 15 days of the release. "Otherwise the offer
shall stand cancelled and no representation be entertained."
Details of the
groups/
services are:
Commerce and Trade Group:
Merit: Muhammad
Ammar Ali Khan (Roll number 2922)
Sheikh Afzaal Raza (Roll number
3440)
Mehwish Khadim (Roll number 2092)
Customs and Excise
Group:
Mahwish Shah (Merit number 16, Roll No 4521)
District
Management Group:
Mehtab Waseem Azhar (Merit number 3, Roll number
2845)
Saadia Tehreem (Merit number 4, Roll number 2182)
Nauman Yousuf
(Merit number 7, Roll number 1303)
Foreign Service of
Pakistan:
Saima Saleem (Merit number 6, Roll number 2219 - subject to
medical Fitness)
Sara Ijaz (Merit number 29, Roll number 2249)
Income
Tax Group:
Muhammad Imran (Merit number 85, Roll number 263)
Muhammad
Asif (Merit number 87, Roll number 2940)
Kiran Maqsood (Merit number 93, Roll
number 2055)
Muhammad Sarim Bhatti (Merit number 94, Roll No
3117)
Information Group:
Adnan Akram Bajwa (Merit number 156, Roll
number 959)
Ateeq-ur-Rehman Khan (Merit number 169, Roll No
2532)
Police Service of Pakistan:
Rizwan Omer Gondal (Merit number
1, Roll number 3330)
Khalil Ahmad (Merit number 2, Roll number 2780)
S
Shehzad Nadeem Bukhari (Merit number 5, Roll No 4368)
Railways (commercial
and transportation) group:
Dr Muhammad Junaid (Merit number 154, Roll
number 4561)
Punjab vacancies:
Pakistan Audit and
Accounts
Service:
Merit: Muhammad Kamran Taufiq (Merit number 99, Roll number
1236)
Muhammad Imran (Merit number 126, Roll number 3006)
Muhammad Sahab
Rehmat (Merit number 140, Roll No 278)
Tehreem Mubashir (Merit number 141,
Roll number 2322)
Aqsa Ali (Merit number 142, Roll number 1933)
Dilshad
Raza (Merit number 144, Roll number 2572)
Shakir Abbas (Merit number 149,
Roll number 3842)
Muhammad Shahid Rafique (Merit number 157, Roll number
3130)
Zillay Fatima (Merit number 158, Roll number 2350)
Raja Ghazanfar
Javed (Merit number 159, Roll number 3297)
Zun Waheed Butt (Merit number 163,
Roll number 2353)
Asif Amin (Merit number 164, Roll number 2513)
Asfa
Maqbool (Merit 166, Roll number 165)
Women:
Nosheen Zakria (Merit
number 171, Roll No 821 - Subject to Medical Fitness)
Abeera Sadaf (Merit
174, Roll number 3646)
Commerce and Trade Group:
Muhammad Usman
(Merit number 106, Roll number 286)
Fahad Raza (Merit number 111, Roll number
2584)
Muhammad Shafiq Haider (Merit number 152, Roll No 3122)
Quratul Ann
Tarique (Merit number 161, Roll number 2144)
Onsia Zafar (Merit number 167,
Roll number 822)
Ashfaq Ahmad (Merit number 168, Roll number 2509)
Customs and Excise Group:
Merit: Falik Shair (Merit 57, Roll
number 2602)
Muhammad Rizwan (Merit number 70, Roll number 277)
Abdul
Mueed (Merit number 72, Roll number 3722)
Omer Bin Zafar Chattha (Merit
number 73, Roll No 3278)
Aneeqa Afzal (Merit number 75, Roll number 1930)
Ammar Ahmadd Mir (Merit number 76, Roll number 2481)
Muhammad Rehan Akram
(Merit number 79, Roll No 275)
Shah Faisal (Merit number 80, Roll number
3838)
Yawar Nawaz (Merit number 81, Roll number 1454)
Women:
Amna Naeem (Merit 91, Roll number 1921)
District Management
Group:
Merit: Syed Muhammad Masood Nouman (Merit number 11, Roll number
318)
Nabila Qadir (Merit number 17, Roll number 2104)
Farvah Aamir (Merit
number 35, Roll number 1993)
Nadia Saquib (Merit number 36, Roll number 2108)
Lubna Rasheed (Merit number 41, Roll number 2059)
Mubeen Illahi (Merit
number 51, Roll number 2867)
Sumaira Zaheer (Merit number 52, Roll number
2295)
Salma Suleman (Merit number 53, Roll number 2232)
Zainab Khan
(Merit number 54, Roll number 2346)
Saira Shafqat (Merit number 56, Roll
number 2229)
Agha Nabeel Akhtar (Merit number 58, Roll number 2413)
Zeeshan Shabbir Rana (Merit number 63, Roll number 3630)
Amina Munir
(Merit number 64, Roll number 1915)
Aman Anwer Kedwaii (Merit number 65,
Roll number 2471)
Kunwar Ejaz Khaliq (Merit number 66, Roll number 1156)
Saima Ali (Merit number 67, Roll number 358)
Women:
Samia
Saleem (Merit number 68, Roll number 2235)
Sidrah Unis (Merit number 71, Roll
number 2287)
Foreign Service of Pakistan
Merit: Umair Ali (Merit
number 48, Roll number 3541)
Muhammad Aneel Zafar (Merit number 49, Roll No
1190)
Nasreen Fatima (Merit number 55, Roll number 2117)
Waseem Shahzad
(Merit number 59, Roll number 3584)
Sibtain Afzaal (Merit number 60, Roll
number 1393)
Rabia Avais (Merit number 62, Roll number 2151)
Liaquat Ali
Warraich (Merit number 69, Roll number 2805)
Waqar Ahmad (Merit number 74,
Roll number 3567)
Women:
Faiza Arshad (Merit number 82, Roll
number 1973)
Income Tax Group:
Merit: Shehryar Akram Awan (Merit
number 100, Roll No 3438)
Sabah Sajid (Merit number 101, Roll number
2190)
Amina Batool (Merit number 104, Roll number 1911)
Murtaza Ali Akbar
Ch (Merit number 105, Roll number 3218)
Yasmin Sadaf (Merit number 108, Roll
number 2341)
Zulfqar Ali (Merit number 110, Roll number 3641)
Samina
Majeed (Merit number 113, Roll number 2239)
Soban Ahmad (Merit number 117,
Roll number 3450)
Naveed Hassan (Merit number 118, Roll number 1305)
Rao
Shahzad Akhter Ali Khan (Merit number 123, Roll number 3318)
Osama Idrees
(Merit number 125, Roll number 3279)
Uzma Waqar (Merit number 127, Roll
number 2339)
Shahzad Ali Khan (Merit number 128, Roll number 3422)
Tanvir Hussain Bhatti (Merit number 130, Roll number 3521)
Ayaz Ahmed
Qureshi (Merit number 131, Roll number 1029)
Sumera Kanwal (Merit number 132,
Roll number 2299)
Waqas Ahmed (Merit number 133, Roll number 3576)
Syed
Hassan Sardar (Merit number 134, Roll number 3480)
Abid Hussain Gulshan
(Merit number 135, Roll number 2389)
Salma Shaheen (Merit number 136, Roll
number 3701)
Sadeea Mazhar (Merit number 137, Roll number 841)
Sana Aslam
Janjua (Merit number 138, Roll number 2243)
Women:
Saba Ijaz (Merit
number 150, Roll number 2187)
Hira Nazir (Merit number 151, Roll number
747)
Information group:
Merit: Akhtar Javed (Merit number 172, Roll
number 2433)
Hina Pervaiz (Merit number 173, Roll number 2020)
Mazhar
Hussain (Merit number 175, Roll number 3766)
Syeda Saira Waris Ali (Merit
number 176, Roll number 908)
Jamil Ahmad Khan (Merit number 181, Roll number
2735)
Ayesha Yasin (Merit number 184, Roll number 3654)
Muhammad Ismail
(Merit number 187, Roll number 3029)
Women:
NIL
Police
service of Pakistan
Merit: Sardar Ghias Gul Khan (Merit number 10, Roll
No 3378)
Amara Athar (Merit number 12, Roll number 1906)
Rana Tahir
Rehman (Merit number 15, Roll number 1329)
Shakir Ahmad Shahid (Merit number
18, Roll number 1385)
Abad Itnisar (Merit number 19, Roll number 2361)
Imran Riaz (Merit number 20, Roll number 2706)
Ismailur Rahman (Merit
number 22, Roll number 3754)
Ibrar Hussain (Merit number 24, Roll number
2678)
Syed Abdul Rahim Sherazl (Merit number 25, Roll No 3457)
Usman
Ijaz Bajwa (Merit number 26, Roll number 3557)
Rana Shoaaib Mehmood (Merit
number 27, Roll No 3311)
Faisal Mukhtar (Merit number 31, Roll number 226)
Muhammad Faisal (Merit number 38, Roll number 1214)
Syed Ali Akbar Shah
(Merit number 40, Roll number 1401)
Waqar Shoeb Anwar (Merit number 42, Roll
number 1445)
Muhammad Tariq Aziz (Merit number 44, Roll number 3159)
Syed Khalid Mehmood Hamdani (Merit number 46, Roll number 3489)
Sayed
Husnain Hader (Merit number 47, Roll number 1356)
Women:
Shaista
Rehman (Merit number 98, Roll number 3706)
Nida Riaz Chatha (Merit number
109, Roll number 2133)
Railways (commercial and transportation)
group:
Merit: Shahbaz Iqbal Malik (Merit number 170, Roll No 3400)
Malik Umair Khan (Merit number 182, Roll number 2823)
Naseer Ahmad Khan
(Merit number 189, Roll number 1297)
Women:
NIL
Postal Group
Merit: Raneem Mubashir (Merit number 186, Roll No 2165)
Saifullah
(Merit number 188, Roll number 3347)
Ammar Nazir Qureshi (Merit number 190,
Roll number 2483)
Women:
NIL
Sindh (rural)
vacancies:
Pakistan Audit and Accounts Service:
Merit:
Nil
Commerce and Trade Group:
Merit: Nil
Customs and Excise
Group:
Merit: Jahanzeb Abbasi (Merit number 155, Roll No
1672)
Women:
Nil
District Management Group:
Merit:
Abdul Shakoor (Merit number 114, Roll number 1578)
Fuad Ghafar Soomro (Merit
number 116, Roll number 1639)
Muhammad Aslam Soomro (Merit number 139, Roll
No 1717)
Women:
Nil
Information Group:
Merit:
Nil
Foreign Service of Pakistan:
Merit: Nil
Income Tax
Group:
Merit: Syed Mashkoor Ali (Roll number
662)
Women:
Nil
Police Service of Pakistan:
Merit:
Tanveer Hussain (Merit number 61, Roll No 665)
Farrukh Raza (Merit number 83,
Roll number 1634)
Samiullah (Merit number 89, Roll number 646)
Bashir
Ahmed (Merit number 165, Roll number 2557)
Syed Mukhtiar Ali Shah (Merit
number 185, Roll No 4770)
Women:
Nil
Postal
Group:
Merit: Nil
Railways (Commercial
and Transportation)
Group
Merit: Nil
Sindh (urban) vacancies:
Pakistan Audit,
Accounts Service:
Merit: Nil
Commerce and Trade
Group:
Merit:
Nil
Customs and Excise Group:
Merit: Ahmed
Ali (Merit number 148, Roll number 1591)
Women:
Nil
District
Management Group:
Merit: Usman Ali (Merit number 32, Roll number
1870)
Syed Nabeel Haider (Merit number 78, Roll number 1852)
Syed
Salahuddin Ahmed (Merit number 103, Roll No 1854)
Women:
Nil
Foreign Service of Pakistan:
Merit: Jasia Sajjad (Merit
number 39, Roll number 756)
Muhammad Kamran Taj (Merit number 43, Roll No
599)
Income Tax Group:
Merit: Nil
Police Service of
Pakistan:
Merit: Zeeshan Shafique Siddiqui (Merit number 8, Roll number
1886)
Arij Jamil (Merit number 97, Roll number
1610)
Women:
Nil
Postal Group:
Merit:
Nil
Railways (Commercial and Transportation) Group
Merit:
Nil
NWFP vacancies:
Pakistan Audit and Accounts
Service:
Merit: Umara Khan (Merit number 120, Roll number
451)
Sajid Ali (Merit number 146, Roll number 4383)
Saiful Islam (Merit
number 178, Roll number 4380)
Women:
Nil
Commerce and Trade
Group:
Merit: Maheen Arshad Khan (Roll number 774)
Customs and
Excise Group:
Merit: Mahmoodur Rahman Khattak (Merit number 37, Roll
number 2809)
Nausheen Riaz Khan (Merit number 45, Roll number
3910)
Women:
Palwasha Syed (Merit number 121, Roll number
2141)
District Management Group:
Merit: Iqbal Hussain (Merit number
13, Roll number 4129)
Saba Asim (Merit number 21, Roll number
2185)
Iftikhar Alam (Merit number 33, Roll number 1104)
Hassan Haren Hote
(Merit number 88, Roll number 1098)
Foreign Service of
Pakistan:
Merit: Azeem Khan (Merit number 95, Roll number
1030)
Shafqat Ullah (Merit number 102, Roll number 1362)
Income Tax
Group:
Merit: Muhammad Hayat Khan (Merit number 107, Roll number
4241)
Sohail Ahmed (Merit number 112, Roll number 4440)
Samiullah Khan
(Merit number 122, Roll number 4393)
Zeeshan Asif (Merit number 124, Roll
number 102)
Maria Mehmood Tirmizi (Merit number 129, Roll No
785)
Information Group:
Merit: Irfan Ashraf Qazi (Merit number 180,
Roll No 1121)
Police Service of Pakistan:
Merit: Fazl-i-Hamid (Merit
number 14, Roll number 1071)
Zahid Nawaz (Merit number 34, Roll number
160)
Muhammad Ateeque Tahir (Merit number 50, Roll No 4223)
Ataur Rahman
(Merit number 84, Roll number 4023)
Women:
Nil
Postal
Group:
Merit: Nil
Balochistan vacancies:
Pakistan Audit,
Accounts Service:
Merit: Nil
Commerce and Trade
Group:
Merit: Nil
Customs, Excise Group:
Merit: Sohaib Anwar
Hashmi (Merit number 119, Roll No 4666)
District Management
Group:
Merit: Habibur Rehman Jamot (Merit number 30, Roll number
4580)
Muhammad Qaseem Khan Kakar (Merit number 86, Roll number
4624)
Foreign Service of Pakistan:
Merit: Ghulam Haider (Merit
number 145, Roll number 4570)
Income Tax Group:
Merit: Shoukat Ali
(Merit number 143, Roll number 4664)
Information Group:
Merit:
Nil
Police Service of Pakistan:
Merit: Agha Ramzan Ali (Merit
number 115, Roll No 2414)
Muhammad Naveed (Merit number 162, Roll number
4622)
Women:
Nil
Postal Group:
Merit: Nil
FATA
vacancies:
Pakistan Audit and Accounts Service:
Merit: Ajmal Khan
(Merit number 147, Roll number 3971)
Commerce, Trade Group:
Merit:
Nil
District Management Group:
Merit: Muhammad Usman (Merit number
9, Roll No 1282)
Foreign Service of Pakistan:
Merit: Muhammad
Junaid Wazir (Merit number 177, Roll number 4262)
Income Tax
Group:
Merit: Nafeesa Bano (Merit number 160, Roll number
803)
Information Group:
Merit: Nil
Police Service of
Pakistan:
Merit: Arif Shahbaz Khan Wazir (Merit number 23, Roll number
1002)
Women:
Nil
AJK vacancies:
Pakistan Audit and
Accounts Service:
Merit: Nil
Commerce, Trade Group:
Merit:
Nil
District Management Group:
Merit: Mariam Mehdi Raja (Merit
number 77, Roll No 2078)
Foreign Service of Pakistan:
Merit:
Muhammad Junaid Wazir (Merit number 177, Roll number 4262)
Income Tax
Group:
Merit: Lubna Said (Merit number 28, Roll number
770)
Information Group:
Merit: Nil
Police Service of
Pakistan:
Merit: Nil
Postal Group:
Merit: Nil
Railways
(Commercial and Transportation) Group:
Merit: Nil
Customs
and Excise Group:
Merit: Nil. * -Daily Times
Your Comments
"It is an irony of our country that persons sitting on the other side of the table are heartless and emotionless. They care about nothing but themselves and their close ones. They have no regards or vision about the country or the younger generation in it. Whereas, we are the one who are trying the clean up the filth created over the past 60 years by our military/civil bureacracy and politicians. All it needs is a single visit to court and police station to develop hatred and mistrust for this country of ours. A youngster having qualification, knowledge and competence is downgraded and overrun by the system. This is the only reason why we are a third world/country. FPSC needs to reconsider its selection procedure and criteria. There is absolutely no doubt that only the competent people get through and to bypass merit means nurturing super-incompetence into the system. I fully support and pray and wish good luck to those candidate fighting for their right. Although they have will gain nothing but shattered heart and envy of FPSC, which will remain a hurdle in their professional civl service career, but still wish you guys and ladies best of luck."
Name: imran sikander
Email: im_124@hotmail.com
City, Country: islamabad, Pakistan
"It is an irony of our country that persons sitting on the other side of the table are heartless and emotionless. They care about nothing but themselves and their close ones. They have no regards or vision about the country or the younger generation in it. Whereas, we are the one who are trying the clean up the filth created over the past 60 years by our military/civil bureacracy and politicians. All it needs is a single visit to court and police station to develop hatred and mistrust for this country of ours. A youngster having qualification, knowledge and competence is downgraded and overrun by the system. This is the only reason why we are a third world/country. FPSC needs to reconsider its selection procedure and criteria. There is absolutely no doubt that only the competent people get through and to bypass merit means nurturing super-incompetence into the system. I fully support and pray and wish good luck to those candidate fighting for their right. Although they have will gain nothing but shattered heart and envy of FPSC, which will remain a hurdle in their professional civl service career, but still wish you guys and ladies best of luck. Tehseen Awan"
Name: Tehseen Awan
Email: tehseenalvi@gmail.com
City, Country: islamabad
|
