Stupid in English | Dcom annual exams
Stupid in English
Dec 04: Learning a language and learning
in a language are two very different things and not recognising the
distinction has a very high social cost.
I thought of this on coming across a news item that the Punjab
government was converting thousands of schools into English medium in "a
bid to bring the quality of education in government-run schools on a
par with private English medium schools".
The issue of the language of instruction, like many others in
Pakistan, has been hanging fire since 1947, switching back and forth at
the whim of individuals seemingly without recourse to any scientific
evidence or critical thinking. No one has computed the costs imposed on
society by the absence of a coherent policy over half a century.
This is not a new topic and much evidence is available from our own
experience. In 1835, Lord Macaulay mandated English as the medium of
instruction in British India from the sixth standard onwards. Even at
the time this was questioned on theoretical grounds by Prinsep, a fellow
member of the Supreme Council, who asked how the English would have
fared if they had been educated in Arabic rather than in the classical
languages of Europe.
Prinsep was overruled but the British themselves picked up the downside of the policy in their review of its implementation.
The 1904 resolution on education policy, referring to the pressures
to introduce prematurely both the teaching of English and its use as a
medium of instruction, was explicit in its conclusion: "This tendency
however should be corrected in the interest of sound education. As a
general rule a child should not be allowed to learn English as a
language until he has made some progress in the primary stages of
instruction and has received a thorough grounding in his mother tongue."
A century later, a British Council report on education in Pakistan
reaffirms the conclusion: "Early years' education must be provided in a
child's home language. The dangers of not doing so include high dropout
levels … poor educational achievement, poor acquisition of foreign
languages (such as English), the long-term decline and death of
indigenous languages, and ethnic marginalisation leading to the growth
of resentment among ethnic minorities."
We can indulge in our favorite pastime of conspiracy-seeking. When
the British mandated English in 1835, it was a conspiracy to cripple our
intellect; when they recommend otherwise in 2010, it is a conspiracy to
cripple our intellect. This reflects nothing more than our crippled
intellect and an inability to assess any proposition on theoretical
merits or against empirical evidence.
Take first the theoretical arguments. The primary objective in the
early years is learning how to think and grasp abstract concepts. At
that point even addition is an abstract concept and seven minus 10 is an
exceedingly abstract one. Language at this stage is a tool to
facilitate learning; it stands to reason to use the most effective tool
available, one in with which the learner thinks and interacts with
others about everything else in his or her world.
Mandating the use of an unfamiliar tool is counter-productive because it adds a layer of translation in the learning process.
An assignment to subtract seven marbles from 10 marbles requires both
a translation of the commodity marble as well as an explanation of the
term 'subtract'. Neither would be required in the mother tongue.
Even this simple example illustrates the extra burden imposed on the
learner. Add to this the fact that the majority of teachers are scarcely
comfortable in English and one can imagine the distortions that would
be occurring in the learning process. Parents taking pride in the
English-medium education of their children are in fact inflicting
immense damage on their learning ability - they are making them stupid
Those not comfortable with cognitive theory can consider empirical
evidence instead. Think of countries like Japan, South Korea and China
that have shown the most remarkable progress since 1947. None have used
English as the medium of instruction at the primary level; all have used
native languages instead. This puts paid to the pervasive argument that
learning in English is crucial for progress in the present times. Had
that been the case, South Asians would have been way ahead of the others
because of their much greater fluency in the English language.
The reality is not only that South Asians are way behind in
development, they are much less innovative as measured by an indicator
like the number of patents filed per capita. This is because South
Asians have lost creativity and critical thinking, turning, by and
large, into babus spouting Shakespeare.
Learning English is indeed important in our times but learning in
English is not the intelligent way to acquire the skill. Many leading
scientists from the non-English-speaking world have learnt as much
English as they need at a later stage in life which reiterates the
general point that a skill is most beneficial when acquired at the
Yet another way to look at the issue is to think of individuals like
Iqbal, Faiz and Salam whom we consider exceptional because of their
achievements. Did they begin their education in English-medium schools
at the expense of languages that contained the knowledge of their
heritage? If not, it should suggest that late acquisition of English is
not a barrier to success.
It is indeed quite possible that an English-medium education would
have consigned them to the ranks of the hundreds of pompous district
commissioners whom no one now remembers.
The issue of the primary language of instruction is not one that
should continue to be treated with casualness. There is a high cost to
society in the loss of creativity and clear thinking and through the
artificial barrier to entry for many creative individuals not
superficially fluent in English. Very soon the decision might not be
left to the muddle-headed few who have risen to the top only by virtue
of having been to English-medium schools and who have subsequently
grossly mismanaged the country and perpetuated poverty by their
prejudiced policy on language.
By Anjum Altaf - The writer is an economist. (Dawn)
"plz tell me date sheet b.com part 11"
City, Country: khi pk
"Excellent. Very sensitive site."
Name: rana jafar
City, Country:lahore pakistan
"asslalm o alikum i need previous model paper of d.com part 2 peshwar board .plz any one send me firstname.lastname@example.org send me email"
Name: usman hameed
Post your comments
D.com annual exams to commence from April 4
Pesahwar: The D.Com Part-I & II Revised Course (2006)/DBA Part-I & II. (New
Course) Annual Examination 2011 of the KPK Board of Technical Education
Peshawar shall commence from April 4, 2011 (Wednesday).
for submission of examination admission forms and fee in the Office of
the Asstt: Controller of Examination (Commerce) KPK Board of Technical
Education Peshawar D.Com (Part-I & Part-II) will be with out late
examination fee of Rs. 570/- upto January 19, with late exam: fee of Rs.
180/- as Rs. 750/- upto January 26, with double fee of Rs. 1140/-
February 2 and with triple exam: fee of Rs. 1710/- February 16, 2011.
dates for submission of examination admission forms and fee for DBA
(Part-I & Part-II will be without late fee of Rs. 640/- January 19,
with late exam: fee of Rs. 180/- January 26 as Rs. 820/- , with double
exam: fee of Rs. 1280/- February 2 and with triple exam: fee of Rs.
1920/- February 16, 2011. It was notified here today by Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa Board of Technical Education Peshawar.
Post your comments
Schools to remain closed
Peshawar: Schools located on routes of Muharram processions will remain closed
while over 3,500 security forces personnel would be deployed across the
provincial capital to maintain law and order during the tense week.
3,500 personnel of the police, Frontier Constabulary and other forces
would be deployed in Peshawar to maintain peace during Moharramul
Haram," said superintendent of police (SP) City Hammad Abid.
to reporters on Friday, he said schools located on routes of Muharram
processions had been directed to remain closed for security reasons. The
official also informed that cops at the Pandu Police Station had
arrested six members of a gang of car-lifters and recovered several
vehicles. He said names of the arrested criminals were being kept secret
for certain reasons. He claimed some influential people were
patronising the gang. The news
Post your comments
Swabi schools lack playing area
Swabi: Like the other 23 districts of Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa, all the 81 government middle schools in Swabi district are
without playground facility, which shows how much the government cares
for the promotion of sports and physical health of students.
Senior officials of the education department said here on Friday
that there was no plan to provide the playground facility to these
educational institutions. They said that like Swabi the all middle
schools of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had no playgrounds.
The officials said that they had brought this into the notice of the top provincial education authorities, but of no avail.
When contacted, heads of several boys and girls middle schools
complained that many government schools had even no physical education
"You are talking about playgrounds; we have no physical education
teachers to conduct co-curricular activities in our schools or maintain
the discipline," said one teacher.
Some headmasters said that each year they conducted the annual sport
activities in the open fields hired for a day from local farmers.
Sources said that headmasters and district sports committee in their
annual meeting demanded that that government should at least reserve one
playground at tehsil level where middle schools could conduct annual
"We need a playground in Swabi, Topi, Chota Lahor and Razaar tehsils
on urgent basis," a headmaster said and added that the government should
do more for promotion of sports in the province to engage youth in
The headmistresses said that due to cultural restrictions girls'
could not play in the open fields and the government should think about
providing them sports facilities, at least at big town level.
They also demanded appointment of physical education teachers in the
newly upgraded schools because the PETs could inculcate the spirit of
sports in their students. Dawn
Post your comments
Timegara: An orientation session was held in the
convocation hall of the University of Malakand for the newly admitted
students in BS 4th year Pharm-D programme to introduce them with
faculty, administration, infrastructure and rules of the university.
The VC Prof Dr M Rasul Jan was chief guest on the occasion, said a press release issued on Friday.
The VC welcomed the students and urged them to come up to the
expectations of their parents and teachers. He said: "I am optimistic to
overcome the challenges faced by our nation and it is based on your
Post your comments