Learning English | Private tuition evil
Jan 09: In a bid to reach greater heights in life, people have
certain values they wish to attain. Over here, it's a given that if you
want to succeed in life then you'd better have a good grasp of the
English language. However, as in all things that happen in this country,
getting the shortcut to success is also the way to succeed when trying
to learn English.
For many households it's not that big a
deal. English is the second language so it's part of the domestic
lingo. At times it's the first language. But there are many others who
want to enter this sphere of 'success'. And so the only way for
desperate parents is to send their children to so-called English-medium
schools so that education there can help them get a grasp of the
dominant language. They are also made to attend tooshan of the highest
calibre. Many of these children are also placed in O- and A-levels
sections, with the sole hope that they will not only learn English but
also excel in their studies.
The problem that many of these
well-intending parents don't realise is that language is not forced onto
someone, especially in our rote-learning system. It can be learnt
properly only when the environment is conducive. Children spend only a
limited time of their day with a teacher who helps them learn the base
of the language. After that, the child is left to the rigours of life,
which include Indian movies, songs and TV shows. Also, at home the
family is conversing in either Urdu or other national languages such as
Pashto, Sindhi, Punjabi, or Gujarati. Thought-processes, too, are made
of these languages.
Another way of improving the language is by
reading books or better newspapers. But even this little task seems too
cumbersome. Parents will be willing to take their children out for fast
food and pay thousands of rupees, but will hesitate when it comes to
taking the kids to a book shop or a book fair. Newspapers are deemed a
waste of money.
Providing the right environment for the children
to learn something - the English language in this case - is the right
way to go about it. Encouraging them to learn a language with the help
of tools like various reading materials should be cheered.
they are more interested in watching TV or cinema, take them out to see
English-language movies, instead of the stuff that we receive from
across the border, which, though meant for adults, is actually deemed
fit for family consumption in our part of the world. But that's another
story for another time.
Just sending the child off to the tuition
centre to learn English thinking that you've done your duty as a
responsible parent is quite irresponsible. Would you do the same with
your business, hand it over to someone to run and not keep a check and balance of what exactly is going on? At the end of the day, it's all about giving attention and creating the right environment. -By Atifuddin Khan
Post your comments
Private tuition a 'necessary evil'
Poor quality of education being imparted in schools has been
instrumental in raising the number of private tuition centres – a shadow
education system - in the country.
The incidence of
private tuition-taking in rural Pakistan among children studying in both
public and private schools is high. The private tuition-taking
prevalence increases with the ability to pay but the average spending on
tuition is roughly the same for poor and rich households though it
imposes a double burden on the poor.
This case was presented by Dr
Monazza Aslam, a researcher at the University of Oxford and the
Institute of Education, University of London, while giving a
presentation on "The 'Shadow' Education Sector in India and Pakistan:
the determinants, benefits and equity effects of private tutoring" at a
seminar. Titled "Trends in privatisation of education and shadow
schooling in Pakistan," the event was organised by South Asian Forum of
Education Development (SAFED) and Idara-i-Taleem-o-Aagahi (ITA) at the
Human Rights Commission of Pakistan this past week.
Dr Monazza, a
Rhodes scholar, said the Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) 2010
survey report revealed that some 15.7 per cent children of 3-16 years
age cohort in rural Pakistan take tuitions and pay Rs293 per month. This
is over and above what parents spend on general schooling - government
Stating that the ASER survey had covered more than 900
villages, more than 19,000 households and more than 54,000 children
aged 3-16 across the country, she said investigations suggested that
children in government schools taking private tuition and especially
those belonging to the poorest classes appeared to perform better than
did not take private tuitions. She said the situation
hinted at the hugely inferior learning the poorest children were
receiving in government schools in rural regions. It also suggested that
private tutoring did appear to substitute for poor quality schooling
for the children in Pakistan.
She said expansion of private
schooling in Pakistan had assumed the proportion of an industry and
changed the dynamics of education provision. "Most significantly large
effects of taking tuition on learning occur in reading."
the children in the poorest and richest quintiles appear to benefit
equally. For instance, she said that "taking tuition increases the
likelihood that a child in the poorest quintile would be able to read a
ITA Director Programmes Baela Raza Jamil spoke about
dimensions of privatisation of public education. Referring to a study
conducted in Rawalpindi and Peshawar in 2011, she said the number of
private schools in both cities' selected urban and rural areas had
witnessed a massive growth.
She said 61 per cent children were
identified as enrolled in private schools, 38 per cent in government
schools and one per cent in madrassahs.
She said the survey of
private schools revealed that 62 per cent of institutions were English
medium and 83 per cent were co-educational. She said the private
schools' enrolment was highest (66.5 per cent) at primary level. She
said 65 per cent of the primary enrolment in private schools was in the
low-cost schools, while in rural areas in both cities the ratio stood at 80 per cent.
She said more than 50 per cent of the teachers in rural and urban Peshawar were paid less than Rs5,000 per month.
Jamil said the study revealed that almost 84 per cent of the
tuition-takers take regular lessons to supplement their school learning,
while meagre one per cent uses tuitions to prepare for entrance tests.
said 68 per cent of the students stated that grade improvement was the
main motivating factor behind the decision to take up private tutoring.
"Peer pressure by friends, parents and even teachers is another major
factor stated as a reason for taking up private tutoring."
Jamil said: "The study informed that facilities in private schools were
slightly better than that in public schools and they offer more choice
to community. However, the cost of education in private sector is high
forcing some households to choose which children or gender to send to
She said the use of relative benchmarks to measure
the quality of public and private sector show that both are bad; private
sector is just lesser of the two evils.
Discussant Dr Yaqoob Khan
Bangash, assistant professor of history at Forman Christian College
University, said more and more children were going to private schools,
while the government had just failed to enact any rules to regulate the
ever-growing private sector.
He said it was unfortunate that
students were more interested in scoring high grades instead of learning
and for this reason also they take up tuitions.
Institute senior adviser Dr Faisal Bari said the implementation of
Article 25-A would be a tough job as the government would be required to
take all children up to matriculation level. This endeavour, he said,
would also change the meaning of examinations. Dawn
Post your comments
Varsities to work for uniform education
Lahore: In view of a severe dearth of specialists to cater to the requirements of the
healthcare sector, the countryís public and private medical universities
and postgraduate medical institutes, under the banner of the Pakistan
National Board, have decided to work together to achieve the targets and
to bring about a uniformity in the postgraduate medical and dental
education at the university level.
The Board has also resolved that the hospitals should be under the control of the universities for a better care of patients.
faces extreme dearth of specialists as there are only 22,000
specialists against the requirement of 225,000 specialists in the
country,î observed the countryís top experts of medical education,
including vice-chancellors, deans and representatives of 18 medical
universities and postgraduate medical institutions of all provinces,
Islamabad and Azad Kashmir under the banner of the Pakistan National
Board during its 4th meeting held recently, sources said here on Sunday.
Prof Azam Yousfani, Vice-Chancellor of Peoples
University of Medical and Health Sciences, Nawab Shah, chaired the
meeting, while vice-chancellors, deans and representatives of the King
Edward Medical University (KEMU), Lahore, Liaquat University of Medical
and Health Sciences, Jamshoro, Postgraduate Medical Institute (PGMI),
Lahore, Punjab University, Lahore, Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto
Medical University (SMBBMU), Larkana, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre
(JPMC University of Karachi), Sindh Institute of Urology and Transplant
(SIUT), Karachi, Armed Forces Postgraduate Medical Institute (AF-PGMI),
Rawalpindi, Quaid-e-Azam University, Islamabad, Pakistan Institute of
Medical Sciences (PIMS) Islamabad and University of Kohat, Kohat, were
While pointing out variance in the postgraduate medical
education in public and private sector in the country, the participants
emphasized the importance of national inter-universities board with a
view to developing a single entrance test for admissions, uniform
curriculum, examination system, structured training and quality
assurance under the control of this national board in order to revamp
postgraduate medical education in the universities and postgraduate
medical institutions in the country. They discussed the role of
universities in postgraduate medical and dental postgraduate education,
research and elevation of academic standards.
meeting, the medical universities and postgraduate medical institutions
signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) for developing a common
framework of level and qualification, uniform entrance test
(constitution of an Admission Board), uniform programmes (constitution
of a national board of all academic programmes) with focus on duration,
curriculum and requirements of research, learning requirements,
examinations (Internal and University), quality assurance and faculty
It has been mentioned that postgraduate medical and
dental education in Pakistan has a history of more than a century as
maiden MD, MS and MDS degrees were awarded in 1914, 1915 and 1935
respectively. Now the number of universities awarding these degrees has
The participants, while pointing out the purpose of
the Pakistan National Board, informed that the member universities under
the banner of the board would work together to improve the quality of
healthcare by improving postgraduate medical education, and for this
purpose, the member universities would create uniform standards of
postgraduate medical education in following areas: duration, entrance
requirements and criteria of number of seats in a similar programme
(beds and teachers ratio with students); criteria to become
supervisor/trainers; evaluation/progression/examination; compulsory
research in program; quality assurance; student exchange; adoption of
best international practices e.g. credit accumulation and transfer
system (EU based), learning strategies and bloom taxonomy of learning
level (USA-based); and criteria to accept past/foreign experience.
was observed that the national board would remove all the discrepancies
in the postgraduate medical education while it would also help
strengthen the university degrees of MS and MD and allow Pakistanis to
capture the market, especially in the Middle East, which was currently
grabbed by the Indian MS and MD degree holders.
elected Prof Azam Yousfani, VC PUMHS Nawabshah, as the president of the
Board for the year 2012 and Prof S.M. Awais from KEMU, Lahore, as the
National Coordinator of the board. The official logo of the Pakistan
National Board was also approved by the participants during the meeting.
The next meeting would be held in the last week of March at KEMU,
Lahore. The news
Post your comments