MBBS entrance test challenged in court
Entrance test result linked to court order
Lahore, July 23: A division bench of the Lahore High Court has linked the result of
the entrance for admission in MBBS to the final outcome of writ petitions
challenging the process of the test.
The court took the decision on
Thursday after Pakistan Medical & Dental Council (PMDC) informed it that the
Punjab government was interfering in its affairs regarding the entrance test.
As proceedings started, PMDC registrar Dr Ahmad Nadeem told the bench
that the council had issued unified rules and regulations for entrance test in
medical colleges throughout Pakistan. The Punjab government and the University
of Health Sciences were duty-bund to abide by the rules.
As per PMDC
criteria, a student who had passed exams of FSc(Per medical) and obtained 60 per
cent marks, was eligible to appear in the entrance test, but the Punjab
government had overlooked these rules and held entry test before the
announcement of FSc result. He pleaded that the result of the test should be
stopped because it would not provide equal opportunities to all students through
out Pakistan. He said that, under rules set by the Punjab government, students
getting 60 or 65 per cent marks would not be able to sit in the test.
The bench comprising Justice Sh. Azmat Saeed and Justice Farrukh Irfan
Khan adjourned the hearing of these petitions for August 19.
petitions were filed before the holding of entry test but the LHC had declined
to issue a stay order against it and the entry test was held by UHS s as per
schedule on July 20.
The bench was hearing a petition filed by Nazifa
Fatima, a student of F.Sc pre-medical, through her counsel Muhammad Azhar
Siddique. The counsel pleaded that the entrance tests were being held prior to
the announcement of the F.Sc result, baring the petitioner from participating in
He said holding the test in such a manner was a violation of
fundamental rights as envisaged in the constitution, adding it was also a
violation of the mandatory instructions issued by the PMDC.
further said that all other provinces were having eligible criteria of 60 per
cent marks in F.Sc. and passing mark of 50 per cent from in the entry test.
But the UHS and chairman admission board for medical/dental institutions
of Punjab without any approval from the PMDC adopted a 60 per cent marks
eligibility criteria in year 2009.
He also pointed out that in the same
year, the respondents while going a step further and while negating the
regulations of PMDC increased the passing marks from 40 to 60 per cent.
Advocate Azhar Siddique requested the court that the criteria for the
entrance test given by the respondents should be declared as without lawful
authority, as it was in conflict with article 9,25, 37 and 38 of the
constitution besides violating the instructions of PMDC.
He said the
respondents might be directed to act strictly according to law and follow the
criteria for holding the entry test as laid down by the PMDC and directions be
issued for holding entry test after the announcement of results of F.Sc.
"it is unjustice with all students that uhs did . i am a student of pre-medical and my exam finished 30 july and i have only 20 days to prepare entry test and it is impossible to read 1-2 year full books. they also increase the passing marks 40 to 60 pertent . they did not declare this before the exams and last year students have almost 5 months for this if there is any law in the world to justice with us and their is no one who ask uhs about this unligle thing.please do some thing about this and i appeal all the students to know their rites. allah bless all of us"
Name: hina bahadar
City, Country: okara
"i truly agree with this writ against uhs. entrance test should be taken after the anouncement of fsc premedical result. and there should be the passing percentage of 40percent for the test."
City, Country: bahawalpur
"What ever policies has been implemented by the Government of Punjab can be revised/reviwed before the date of enterane test. Now its not fair to review and revise after the entery test, as a huge numer of students already spent their time and money to complete this lenghty process. If the court or goverment is welling to change any policy about the entry test then it should be implemented from the coming next year"
City, Country: Gilgit Pakistam
"UHS is unfair and highly unloyal to students.We were told about entry test just 20 days befor the announced date.It was just impossible to preapre 6 bookseach containing 300 pages,in 20 days.MIAN SHAHBAZ SHAREEF,so called well wisher of students,should have think for a moment before taking such decision.Entry test should be repaeated again or passing percentage must be reduced frm 60percent to 40percent as it was before,"
Name: Adnan ali
"it is not fair with students,i think all students should disagree with uhs."
"i am strongly in favour of comments presented by the Dr ***** ***** registrar of PMDC about the entry test for the admition test for MBBS which is conducted against the rules and regulations framed by PMDC. This entry test did not provide the students sufficent time for the revision of syllabous as a result of which a number of genous stugents have not only obtained very less marks bout have failed. so this entry test shoule be cancelled and new should be conducted after providing appropriate time for study and violation of basic human rightes should be stopped. The honourable LHC should play its vital role in maintaing the superiority of law and the protection of Basic Human rights.Moreover i ask the students to present their openion on this delicate issue of carrier development thanks naveed iqbal"
Name: Naveed iqbal
"To conduct ENTRY TEST by the UHS before the announcement of result and without giving the students reasonable time for study is openly the violation of basic human rights, due to which a number of good achivers of marks has failed due to non revision of 6 books within only 20 days given by the UHS. Honorable LHC should tanke notice on this delicate issue of students carries and should pass order for UHS to recoduct the entry test after giving the students proper time for study. Thanks Muhammad Asim Naveed"
Name: M.Asim Naveed
"what is the w8tage of entry test in 2010 plz tell me about this to my email adress thanks"
Name: muhammad waqas
"I am totally agreed with writ against UHS.They have no right to decide our future by a three hour test.and if the test is necessary to tke place.It should be after FSc result.and passing marks should be 40% instead of 60percent.thanks"
Name: Ahmad Mujtaba
"I thnk if anythng hd to be done then it should had been before all this!!What is the condition of justice in our country?All the students hav prepared for MCAT and hav wasted thier tym & aloooooot of money!!We are the students of FBISE.What if all the students whether deserving or not,from Lahore Board will become eligible for applying in MBBS??The only fair solution is that there should be a low merit for MBBS this year.So all tha deserving candidates who fulfill it would be able to apply for MBBS.Plz students try to make our govt. adopt this criteria."
"i thnk the test should b held again....the students were not even given enough time to go through all the syllabus...the test was supposed to b held in october and the date was suddenly announced when we were least xpecting it...i would call it injustice...and the proof is the result of the entry test...for the students who hv just appeared in FSc it was a shock...therefore i think the test should b held again...according to all the rules."
Name: Maryam Hanif
"NOW ENTRY TEST HAVE BEEN DONE.SO THERE SHOULD NOT BE ANY PROBLEM.THERE IS NO CHANCE OF REVIEWING ENTRY TEST.SO LISTS SHOULD BE DISPLAYED ACCORDING TO MERIT.IT IS THE PLACE FOR THE BEST."
Name: aftab sharif
City, Country:multan pakistan
"it is completely unjust to take the entry test in very short time after exams. and eligibility should be 40 or 50 percent"
"this test was a total violation of PMDCs rules regarding the medical entrance exam i am not saying that the time for preparation was insufficient but the thing is that student must have been told about this before the 2nd year exams so that they might prepare themselves properly for the situation but the stupids and idiots informed them less than a month before the test and if anybody says that how come some of the students managed to get 1000 plus marks then the answer is that the paper might be according to their minds or the questions were from the portions they had prepared better andthere is a 100percent chance of them being lucky and one more thing that the passing marks should be those that are standard in our country that is 40percent to 50percent.Thats it .Thank you."
Name: Muhammad Qousain Ali
"UHS wanted to discourage the academies for the preparation of entry test but every such academy has earned more than ever this year instead of going to loss and this shows that it was a plan reduce the students of medical field this is a very negative approach and I PRAY EVERYONE INVOLVED IN THIS DECISION WILL INSHALAH BE BURNT IN THE WORST RANKS OF HELL FOR RUINING SO MANY LIVES"
City, Country: okara,pakistan
"i think entry test should not be held again. students have already put up all their potential by doing harsh studies if it will held again then it is totally unjustice for the students who have already passed it."
City, Country: gujranwala
"Asslam-o-Alikum !!! i am also agree with the writ against the UHS....so please i with my friends request you to decrease the pass percentage from 60 to 40 pleasssse thank you"
Name: Rabeea Javed
City, Country: Pattoki Pakistan
"i agree with the appeal of the student who challenged entry test 2010 in court..the merit should be decreAsd from 60 to 40 percent..we should have right to study in our own country seeking justice."
Name: SARA TARIQ
City, Country:jhang sadar punjab
"i agree with the writ against UHS as they gave very short time to us for the preparation of M CAT.....!!! Entry test should be taken after the announcement of Fs.c Result.........!!!!!"
Name: Muhammad Usama khalid
City, Country:Lahore, Pakistan
"Entry test is held now. Students have wasted their energies n resources for its preparation. So if anything had to be done, it would have been done before the test....."
City, Country: Multan
"uhs failed or less marks no problem get guranteed admision in mbbs. In top universities n coleges of pakistan. Min marks 60%. No test required. contact now... Dr. Qureshi. **************** ************* "
Name: Dr. Qureshi
City, Country:karachi, pakistan
"What happened on 19 August hearing? Does any body know the proceedings of that day?"
Name: Khalid Farooq
City, Country:Lahore, Pakistan
"i think test should be held again so that we may get sufficient time to prove ourself plz all the students must take steps in favour of this writ plz it is metter of our future plz do something so that test must be held again!thank u!"
Name: qurat ul ane
City, Country:burewala pakistan
"it was really injustice. but what is done is done..Now if the court decides the test to be conducted again.well again have 20 days 4 preparation... now only decrease in % can save our future! good luck for your future n pray for the decrease in percent regardz !!!"
"i think uhs done very bad with us nobody even reads its complete syllabus,i think it is not fine do something for us ours hopes were deing due to them (uhs)"
"yah i m also participating in this entrance exams but i missed..now i dont now what is going on in board university...it is turely unfair with us.."
"asalam-o-alaikum, its saqlain(last year student of electrical engg. uet lahore) it is really injustice with the innocent medical students that punjab government had held the mbbs entrance test before the fsc result announcement. and also students have to avail a very short period for test preparation. government must think that it is the matter of students future and must also think upon to held again mbbs entrance test. best wishes for medical students."
Name: salqain tahir
City, Country:jhang, pakistan
"i know entry test has held again plz tell me when will be this test and what is elligibility criteria for this test plz plz plz plz tell me the exact date of the test plz!....."
City, Country:lahore pakistan
"the student who got 1058 have also the same time for preparation. And there are so many examples. so UHS does not do any UNJUSTICE."
Name: junaid nawaz
"600 students scored 900+ .. They Also had the same time for preparation."
City, Country: Gujranwala,Pakistab
"Soo depressing, for me it was my life becaming a doctor, so much dreams. During the test I lost my senses k I must clear otherwise I wont be a doctor. Mr shabz sharife we voted ur family but there is no well being of us. If ur daughter wanted to be doctor. U could make her private. wat bot us? think n take a step. Its a strong urge to full dreames of my parents n my owns and to serve humanity truly."
City, Country: Rawalpindi, Pakistan
Post your comments
UET budget approved
Lahore: The syndicate of University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore, approved the annual budget of
the university for 2010-2011. UET Vice-Chancellor Lt Gen (Retd) Muhammad Akram
Khan chaired the meeting. According to a press release here on Thursday, the
total income for the recurring budget for 2010-2011 is estimated at Rs 1910.244
million. Expenditure has been estimated at Rs 2076.165 million with the deficit
of Rs 165.921 million. This budgetary shortfall has occurred mainly due to
recent increase in pay, pension and allowances announced by the government. An
estimated development budget of Rs 670 million has also been passed for the
various campuses of the UET, Lahore.
Post your comments
PU awarded PhD
Lahore: The Punjab University has awarded a PhD degree to Vafa Yazdan Manesh d/o Ali in the subject
of Urdu after the approval of research thesis titled "Urdu Gazaliat Main Farsi
Talmihat-o-Tarakeeb Lisani-o-Tehqiqi Mutalaa (Az Wali Ta Iqbal)." She completed
her thesis under the supervision of Prof Dr Tehsin Firaqi, Chairman PU Urdu
Post your comments
PU LLM result
Lahore: The Punjab University Examinations Department has announced the result of LLM, final,
annual examination 2009. Detailed results are also available on PU website
Post your comments
PU LLB date-sheet
Lahore: The Punjab University Examinations Department has announced the
written examination date-sheet of LLB, Part-III, annual examination 2010.
According to details, the exam will commence from August 11 and conclude on
September 3, 2010. Detailed date-sheet is also available on PU website
Post your comments
PPSC recommends 39 candidates
Lahore: The Punjab Public Service Commission (PPSC) on Thursday
recommended 39 candidates including two under female quota to the provincial
government for appointment against 40 posts of Veterinary Officer in BS-17 in
the Directorate of Breed Improvement, Punjab Livestock and Dairy Development
The PPSC also recommended 11 candidates to the provincial
government for appointment against to the posts of Livestock Production Officer
BS-17 in the Directorate of Smallholder, Dairy Development, Gujranwala,
Livestock and Dairy Development Department.
Details of the results can be
seen on Commission's website www.ppsc.gop.pk, said a press release here on
Thursday. The news
Post your comments