No libraries, no books
April 24, 2008: Upon getting back to the US after two years in Pakistan,
I spent a few exhilarating hours in the local library.
Libraries here are
a pleasant relaxing space for learning, with easy access to all forms of
knowledge, books, video, music, newspapers, magazines and the internet. You can
read sitting at a table, on easy chairs or even lying down. You can sleep there
too. There are even rooms to arrange meetings, talks or seminars in. And here we
are talking of local public libraries only. University libraries are large,
architecturally delightful and extremely pleasant spaces that operate very long
hours and are designed for kids to virtually live there.
Most of all,
there is no bureaucracy in any of these libraries. In public libraries,
volunteers assist you with the minimum of rules. All you have to do is show them
proof of address. It takes five seconds to get a library card and I can borrow
about 20 books, videos and other items at a time. And these libraries are open
late and over the weekends. They will facilitate your research and reading
through inter-library loans. This means I can get any book through my library as
it stands ready to borrow from other libraries to meet my
Libraries have been the hallmark of growing and progressive
civilisations. Even in Sumer libraries of clay tablet writing have been found.
Classical Greece and its love for books and learning gave us civilisation. Even
the Persian Empire had libraries in Persepolis when Alexander attacked. Roman
emperors too set up libraries to be remembered all over the empire. Then there
was the famous library of Alexandria which till the early middle ages held most
of human knowledge.
'By the 9th Century completely public libraries
started to appear in many Islamic cities. They were called "halls of knowledge"
or dar al-'ilm. They were each endowed by Islamic sects with the purpose of
representing their tenets as well as promoting the dissemination of secular
knowledge. But, then, do not forget that fanaticism and conquest has always
sought to close society. Their main weapon has been closing down places of
worship and libraries.
In recent history, libraries have flourished in
all progressive and well-managed countries. When we visit the British Museum we
are stunned by the huge, airy reading room of the British Library in the heart
of London. Their website proudly announces: "We hold over 13 million books,
920,000 journal and newspaper titles, 57 million patents, 3 million sound
recordings, and so much more."
In 1800, the Americans established the
Library of Congress by an act of Congress. "Today's Library of Congress is an
unparalleled world resource. The collection of more than 130 million items
includes more than 29 million catalogued books and other print materials in 460
languages; more than 58 million manuscripts; the largest rare book collection in
North America; and the world's largest collection of legal materials, films,
maps, sheet music and sound recordings."
Civilised governments have built
these repositories of knowledge as national monuments to show how important
learning and knowledge is. These grand buildings and their large holdings will
remain through history as testaments to these great civilisations many eons from
now. Most serious countries have not only large national libraries but also
large networks of local public libraries. Most communities in the US and Europe
and many countries have libraries with adequate library resources. In England
this network started in the 17th and 18th Centuries and is now extremely large,
with every locality having a library nearby. In the US another act of Congress
initiated the public library system in 1850.
In our history, we have
built lovely official residences such as the President's House, governors'
houses, the Prime Minister's House and many other buildings, but no libraries.
We have built many polo grounds and golf courses, but no libraries. Lahore, an
ancient city of culture, now has more polo grounds than libraries. Lahore even
has more offices for the chief minister (four in all) than libraries. Of course,
the Chief Minister needs office space more than our children need libraries.
A search for libraries on the internet reveals only university and
organisational libraries in Pakistan. When you go to university and
organisational libraries, you see what a sorry state these are in. They hardly
have a collection and are operated like bureaucracies with severe entry
limitations and on a short working day, mostly during office hours.
have no public libraries, beyond what the British left us. The Quaid-e-Azam
Library in the old Company Bagh in Lahore (now Bagh-e-Jinnah) is nothing but a
bureaucratic enterprise with severe entry limitations and hardly a serious
collection. It even does not boast a website in the year 2008.
national library did not even get space on the main Constitution Avenue. It is
tucked away behind the prime minister's office as if we were ashamed of it. As
its website puts it, it is in a plot of 500 by 100; a little over an acre is all
the government could afford for a library. It took us 46 years to come up with
the concept for a national library. Even today the National Library has 130,000
volumes, 555 manuscripts, 45 reels of microfilms, 48,000 microfiche cards, 845
magazines and 135 newspapers. What a testament of our great civilisation! I
might add that this collection does not even compare to a reasonable sized
public library in a civilised country.
In Pakistan I witnessed our
bureaucracy and the Planning Commission in this game called "who can spend our
development money the fastest on pet projects?" I saw many strange projects like
megabuck universities contracted to unknown consortiums, bureaucracies setting
up mango-pulp and football-making plants, textile cities, garments cities, and
so many others. I asked and wondered why we cannot have projects for community
libraries. Why can we not dedicate, say, about Rs50 million for a library n the
top 20 cities of our country per year. That is only a billion a year. Not a
large sum of money when you think of the vanity projects, VIP trips and the sums
required to maintain our VIPs.
But then I was reminded of who demands
books in Pakistan? When I go to my rich friends' houses, I see no books. A
million-dollar household with a hundred-thousand-dollar sports car outside has
no books. Rich people who spend thousands of dollars on a dinner do not even
spend 100 dollars annually on books. None of our political manifestoes even
mention libraries. So perhaps the government is right. There is no demand for
libraries in our country.
Nadeem Ul Haque (The News)
The writer is a former vice-chancellor of the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics.
|Post your Comments/ Views about the news.|