World Bank (WB) report on Pakistan education
Massive increase in private schools between 2001-5: WB report
Karachi, April 21, 2008: Within a span of five years, the number of private schools in the
country has increased from 32,000 to 47,000, while the overall enrolment has
increased by 10 per cent between 2001 and 2005. Meanwhile, only one-third of
children at the primary level study at private schools, according to a recent
report released by the World Bank (WB).
The WB report calls for
reevaluation of education polices in the context of a dramatic increase in
private schools for primary education in Pakistan. The report says that the
quality of education at public schools is lacking, and children at private
schools score significantly higher than those at public schools, even if they
are from the same village.
The WB report presents facts and figures from
a survey of public and private schools in 112 villages in Pakistan, and lays out
important policy options to facilitate evidence-based policymaking. For-profit
private schools have become a widespread presence in both urban and rural areas,
and provide parents with an alternative option for investing in their children's
education, the report says.
It advances a modified role of the
government for discussion and debate. This would focus on policies complementary
to, rather than in competition with, the private sector. One strand of this
modified role would be for the government to provide information.
report suggests, for instance, that information on the quality of every school,
public or private, would enable households to make informed decisions and
increase beneficial competition between schools. It also proposed that the
government correct imbalances arising from unequal geographical access to
private schools, and ensure that all children acquire a set of basic
competencies. Lastly it urges the government to become an innovator willing to
experiment with and evaluate 'out-of-the-box' reforms such public-private
partnerships where financial support is given to children regardless of the
The report further says that improving quality in
government schools requires rethinking teacher hiring and compensation in a
fundamental manner. It presents a number of different options for teacher reform
ñ from decentralizing teacher hiring to decreasing additional duties such as
attending workshops and administering polio vaccinations to performance based
pay. The report clarifies that each option has its won strength and weaknesses
and debate and discussion are required to inform the way forward.
Finally, the report says educational policies need to recognize that
there are weaknesses and strengths in both sectors. The relative strengths of
the government sector are a better educated and trained workforce that is
The relative strengths of the private sector are
the ability to cut costs by paying teachers according to local conditions and
performance and eliciting higher levels of efforts from their teachers.
Teachers' absence in govt schools increases: WB
Islamabad: A World Bank (WB) report reveals that the absenteeism in public
sector schools increased at senior level owing to various reasons including
election duties or participation in district level meeting of education
But this absenteeism of public sector school teachers also
resulted into increased pay and other perks and privileges rather than reducing
it, thus quality of education compromised when teachers are not present in
The World Bank arranged a dissemination conference of Learning
and Educational Achievement in Punjab Schools (LEAPS) report here at the Bank's
office on Saturday.
The LEAPS team included Tahir Andrabi, Jishnu Das,
Ijaz Khawaja, Tara Vishwanath and Trsistan Zajonc. The LEAPS team conducted
survey of 112 villages of Punjab to assess the quality of education in
The participants of the conference pointed out that the private
school owners are exploiting teachers by giving them too much low salaries thus
there is requirements to bring regulation in this sector.
However, the WB
experts were of the view that there was no need of such regulations because it
would result into discouraging the private investors to provide education
facilitates where the government remained unable to deliver in an effective
The LEAPS team pointed out that the public sector teachers are
more qualified and trained compared to private sector. The private sector
teachers having qualification of MA are just 4 percent whereas MA degree holders
in public sector are around 90 percent.
The private school teachers are
mostly female and a major chunk of them dropped out after their
The WB team also found that the salaries of government school
teachers are five time more than the private school teachers. Despite this fact
that the teachers are more trained in public sector but there is no positive
impact on learning of students. "More training of public sector school teachers
resulted into increased increments and salaries and there is no benefit to
students in terms of improved learning," they added.
The LEAPS team also
asked the government to focus more on improving the performance of teachers
rather than constructing infrastructure. There should also be accountability
mechanism for checking the performance of the teachers, the team further
While overall enrolments increased by 10 percent between 2001 and
2005. The report says quality of education is lagging and children perform
significantly below curricular standards for common subjects and concepts at
Children in private schools score significantly higher
than those in government schools, even when they are from the same village. In
fact, it will take children in government schools 1.5-2.5 years of additional
schooling to catch up to where private school children are in class 3. Better
learning results in private schools do not arise from higher costs, it costs
half as much to educate a child in a private school (Rs1000 per year) compared
to a government school (Rs2000 per year).
The report advances a modified
role of the government for discussion and debate. This modified role of the
government would focus on policies complementary to, rather than in competition
with, the private sector.
One strand of this modified role would be for
the government to provide information. The report suggests, for instance, that
information on the quality of every school - public or private - would enable
households to make informed decisions and increase beneficial competition
between schools. The suggestion is based, in part, on the results of an ongoing
Randomised Control Treatment Experiment.
It also proposes that the
government corrects the imbalances arising from unequal geographical access to
private schools, and ensures that all children acquire a set of basic
Lastly, it urges the government to become an innovator
willing to experiment with and evaluate "out-of-the-box" reforms such as
public-private partnerships where financial support is given to children
regardless of the school chosen. The News
|Post your Comments/ Views about the news.|